Finished my latest edit of Book 10 of The Demonata
today. I know I'll have to go through it at least another 3 or 4 times
over the next year and a half, before it's ready to be published, but
I'm very pleased with how it currently stands -- as I've said here
before, I think it's a suitably action-packed, twisting, vicious
finale, which should leave most fans with the big smile you get on your
face when you finish a long series and find the ending more than
matches your expectations. That happened to me with The Sopranos
the other night, when I saw the final episode -- even though it was
rather open-ended, which infuriated many fans, the episode built
brilliantly and left me smiling sadly at the end, happy because it was
great, sad because it was over. The best ending to a TV series ever, in
my view, was Six Feet Under
-- when that finished, I did something I've never done before or since,
and immediately rewound to watch the last several minutes again. I'm
hoping the tenth book of The Demonata has something of a similar impact on fans, although of course only time will tell ...
Went to see the movie of The Golden Compass
tonight. Wow. Just ... wow!!! I often get asked in interviews what my
favourite books by current writers are. I always give the same answer
-- although I like a lot of authors at the moment, such as Anthony
Horowitz, Eoin Colfer, J K Rowling, Marcus Sedgwick, etc, I think His Dark Materials
blew everything else out of the water, and I judge the three books
taken together to be probably the best thing to happen to the book
world in the last ten years. They were fresh and stunningly paced and
structured, and they had a huge impact on me when I read them -- they
made me want to raise my game, to stretch myself further, to try to
push my imagination as far as Pullman pushed his. I don't know if The Demonata would have been quite as ambitious as it turned out to be if I hadn't read His Dark Materials. I suspect not.
But
that meant, of course, that the movie had a hell of a lot to live up
to. I never worry about a film "spoiling" a book. I know it's something
that troubles many fans, and I must admit it used to trouble me when I
was a teenager -- I lived in fear of a Judge Dredd
movie that failed to do the comics justice. But these days I look upon
films as something entirely separate, which they are. A book doesn't
change when a film of it is made -- if the book was good or bad before
the film, it will be equally good or bad afterwards. Most film
adaptations are dire (just as book adaptations of films would probably
be dire if there were lots of them), but I think it's worth letting
Hollywood at books because there's always a chance they'll hit gold and
make another Godfather or Lord of the Rings or Shawshank Redemption. Chances are they probably won't, but hell, what's the point of living if we refuse to take a gamble?!?
The Golden Compass
movie is definitely one of the finer adaptations around, especially of
a fantasy novel. For the most part Hollywood does fantasy fairly
craply. It's difficult to make a tale of magic work on the big screen
-- things that fire your imagination on the page can look ridiculous
when brought to life, especially if the film-makers don't have a lot of
money. But when a fantasy film works, it can be truly spectacular. And The Golden Compass
is just that -- a huge, ambitious, intelligent, beautiful, neatly paced
epic, standing heads and shoulders above most other similar movies. Of
course it changes things from the book, but far less than it might have
done, and mostly for the best -- things that work well in books don't
always translate to the screen, and only a fool tries to film a book
exactly as it's written. My only gripe would be the ending -- they stop
short of the finish in the book, to give it more of a positive finale.
I can fully understand why they did that -- they're anxious to make the
next two films, but this one has to make a lot of money in order for
them to press ahead, so they were wary of ending on a downer and
sending viewers away miserable -- but it still disappointed me. But, in
the overall scheme of things, it was a minor disappointment. This was
the best time I've had in a cinema for quite some time. HIGHLY
recommended!!!! It also excited me because Paul Weitz (the director of
the Cirque Du Freak movie) was one of the executive producers on this film -- let's hope he brings some of the magic from The Golden Compass on with him to Cirque Du Freak ........
Posted at 10:58 pm by
Darren_Shan
 |  |  |
David Brett-Andrews November 18, 2008 01:47 AM PST
I must be the only one here who hated that film. I mean, visually it was stunning and almost everything in it worked for me but, seriously, I hated the girl who played Lyra - she just seemed so wooden!
Eh, but maybe that's just me, having gone to it expecting the same things of it as with movies like the unsurpassable Lord of the Rings trilogy.
Dave |
 |

 |  |  |
maitlin December 27, 2007 06:41 PM PST
HEY DARREN!!!
I absolutely LOVED the HIS DARK MATERIALS series! I haven't had the chance to go out and see the movie yet but I've been planning to go since it came out. If you suggest it I'm definately gonna beg my mom today! LOL
also - craply? you mean crapy right
<3 mAitY <3
uRoKmIsoXxOfF
loloolol |
 |

 |  |  |
Maisie December 19, 2007 08:55 AM PST
the Demon Apocolypse cover rite. the person there isit lord Loss?
=) |
 |

 |  |  |
Maisie December 19, 2007 08:51 AM PST
There's a Demonata book 10? And a book 7 & 8 & 9? When will it come out? Oh, do hurry i wanna read it!!! it's like my fave books haha.
Bill-E died rite? you mean died forever or like Bec. pls pls pls hurry up with the books!
Longing to read them, Maisie |
 |

 |  |  |
Kathryn Winstanley December 17, 2007 01:20 AM PST
Hi Darren! :)
Ah! The only thing I know I'll feel for the last Demonata book will be sadness, even though I'm very very excited to find out what happens I also don't wan't it to end! Hehe!
Oh, what a counsidence, I wen't and saw The Golden Compass today too, well, for the second time actually! I just loved it so much I had to see it again, I haven't read the books before but I really enjoyed the movie! It was very interesting! :)
From your huge fan Kathryn :) |
 |