I've been hard at work on editing City of the Snakes.
I've been getting through more than 50 pages every day. I haven't had
to make any real structural changes, just tighten it up a lot. There
was a nice twist halfway through, a scene that made me grin when I came
back to it again. Most of the time when I'm writing, I don't think
about my audience or consider how people are going to react. But every
so often I find myself thinking about my readers and how they'll
respond, and those are some of the best moments of writing for me. I'm
certain, when people who've read the first two books come to this
point, they're going to have the same grin on their faces that I had
when I hit it yesterday, and that connection - even though nobody will
get to read the book for another two years - pleases me greatly. What's
even better is that it's a twist that sharp readers will be able to
anticipate if they're paying attention, but one that I think most will
miss. Those are always my favourite twists -- the ones which are
obvious in retrospect (such as the one involving the title in Book 12
of The Saga, or Harkat Mulds
or Juni Swan's true identities), but which most readers never realise
until it's revealed, at which point they groan, "Why the hell didn't I
see THAT coming?!?"
Of course, those who DO see it coming never
have quite the same reaction -- indeed, some don't like it when I allow
them to second-guess me; they want complete surprises, twists that are
impossible to predict. (They're wrong, by the way, as I've said before
-- the best twists are always those which can be predicted. A good
story should always signpost its twists, not TOO obviously, but having
unexpected things happen all the time, just to keep throwing readers,
is bad story-telling.) Those people often find it hard to believe that
not all readers saw what they saw. Like those who figured out the twist
in The Sixth Sense, they
think that surely EVERYONE must have been able to do it, since - to
them - it's so obvious. But that's the trick about a really cool twist
-- yes, it IS obvious when you figure it out, but most people don't!!!
After book 10 of The Saga
came out, my Message Boards were full of people claiming they'd cracked
the Harkat mystery far in advance, and saying how obvious it was, and
anyone who didn't see it coming was a fool -- but I have a long memory,
and I can't recall more than 2 or 3 mentioning it before that book was
released. Maybe all those super-sleuths kept quiet beforehand, so as not to spoil the twist for others. Or maybe they were just being wise after the fact ...
Anyway, I love a good, slyly telegraphed twist, and City of the Snakes contains one of my favourites, so I hope you all enjoy it when you get to read the book in 2010!!!!
On the movie front, recently I saw Notes on a Scandal,
a very sly, dark comedy (or tragedy, depending on how you look at it),
brilliantly acted and sharply paced -- strongly recommended. I finally
caught up with The Faculty (I can't believe I never saw it before!!), and while it's totally throwaway trash, it's nicely handled and lots of fun. Thank You For Smoking
is an amusing satire of the spin-doctor syndrome, which neatly avoids
the sentimental pitfalls such films normally fall into. And I've just
seen half of the third Pirates of the Caribbean
film -- I'll probably watch the second half later tonight. Johnny Depp
is still wonderful as Captain Jack, and the effects are commendable,
but boy is it long!!! The second film was at least half an hour too
long, and this one's even longer!! I really do enjoy this series, but
how much better it would have been if someone had just told the
director to make each segment no longer than two hours ...
Aaarrrrrrr!!!!!!
Posted at 08:07 pm by
Darren_Shan
 |  |  |
Kathryn Winstanley January 11, 2008 05:43 PM PST
Hi Darren! :)
Wow, You are editing loads, 50 pages must have taken you forever!
Oh, I agree about the twist thing, like you said, book 12 of the saga was so obvious when you read the book, but before I didn't have a clue, on anything like Harkat Mulds, I didn't have a clue, but it was so obvious once you read it!
Thats one of the things that makes your books so good, I just love them!
Pirates of the Caribbean is a little long I agree, I really liked it anyway, but taking a little time out of it would have made it much better! :)
From your huge fan Kathryn! :) |
 |

 |  |  |
Nicholas January 11, 2008 12:51 PM PST
Completely agree about the third Pirates of the Caribbean film being too long. The only film that I have been sitting there going "FINISH DAMN IT!!", apart from when I went to see Epic Movie. What a load of s- |
 |